Note: Our comparison table only shows our top 3 picks. You can find the other recommendations within this article.
You’re more likely to buy the best decaf K-cups because they’re more convenient. I mean, who has the time AND patience to prepare coffee using a pot anymore, right? When fast preparation meets great coffee taste, why would you want to choose anything else?
What’s more, compact pods don’t leave any stray beans or ground coffee on the countertop. You won’t even have to deal with that mess.
The brewer simply pours hot water over your K-cup, and you have that breakfast blend ready within a minute with just the right amount of smokiness.
But here’s the thing about K-cups: there are many out there.
Therefore, it’s a tricky business differentiating between the good and the bad.
Here are the top-rated best k-cups, the decaffeinated kind, of course.
Table Of Contents
- Our Reviews for the Best 9 Decaf K-Cups for Your Keurig
- #1 San Francisco Bay Onecup Decaf French Roast
- #2 Newman’s Own Organics Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup Pods
- #3 Organic Coffee Co. Onecup Gorilla Decaf
- #4 Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Dark Magic Decaf
- #5 Tully’s Coffee French Roast Single-Serve Keurig K-Cup
- #6 Peet’s Coffee Decaf House Blend Dark Roast Coffee
- #7 The Original Donut Shop Single-Serve K-Cup Pods
- #8 Starbucks Decaf Pike Place Roast K Cups
- #9 Green Mountain Coffee Medium Roast K-Cups
- Different Types of Decaffeinated K-Cups
- Factors to Take Into Consideration When Buying Decaf K-Cups
- FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Our Reviews for the Best 9 Decaf K-Cups for Your Keurig
- San Francisco Bay Onecup Decaf French Roast
- Newman’s Own Organics Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup Pods
- Organic Coffee Co. Onecup Gorilla Decaf K-Cups
- Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Dark Magic Decaf K-Cups
- Tully’s Coffee French Roast Single-Serve Keurig K-Cup
- Peet’s Coffee Decaf House Blend Dark Roast Coffee K-Cups
- The Original Donut Shop Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup Pods
- Starbucks Decaf Pike Place Roast K Cups
- Green Mountain Coffee Medium Roast K-Cups
#1 San Francisco Bay Onecup Decaf French Roast
There’s no chance you won’t savor the rich, complex, bold, smoky, and intense blend of the San Francisco Bay OneCup Decaf. It comes in environment-friendly pods, crafted with plant-based and renewable resources!
The beans are shade-grown responsibly and then expertly handpicked.
But it’s the smoky flavor that I’m convinced you might relish the most. It’s what makes the taste so unrivaled.
The bitterness is minimal and the flavor the most robust. That’s the charm of this French roast. So who makes the best decaf K-cups?
It’s San Francisco Bay, no doubt. And finally, these cups are compatible with Keurig 1.0 and 2.0 brewers.
- Full-bodied, bold decaffeinated coffee
- Eco-friendly and commercially compostable K-cups
- Very smooth dark roast with no bitterness
- Grounds tend to seep through filter
- Mesh bottom, thus airtight storage required
#2 Newman’s Own Organics Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup Pods
Here’s presenting another set of highly recommended decaf K-cups.
The Newman’s Own Organics Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup Pods are almost miraculous. If you’re a caffeine lover like me, you can take my word for it.
The incredibly complex flavor is what speaks the loudest here.
These single-serve K-cups have a lot going in terms of aroma, taste, and finish. But first, let me tell you that they’re suitable for all Keurig K-cup coffee makers.
As for the blend, I found it to be simply strong and delicious. As would you, I’m quite certain! There’s no unpleasant aftertaste either if that’s what’s on your mind.
High-quality coffee is not easy to find, trust me. So when you do, it’s best to never let go. That’s why I am sure you’ll love the Newman’s Own Special Blend Decaf.
- Strong, smooth, bold medium roast
- USDA Organic, Kosher, and Fair Trade certified
- Refreshing flavor packed with consistency and smoothness
- Sadly, no oily coffee bean taste or rich aroma
#3 Organic Coffee Co. Onecup Gorilla Decaf
It’s time to befriend the best organic decaf K-cups.
They come in the form of Organic Coffee Co. DECAF Coffee, and as is expected, the taste is not on the stronger side.
But that’s a good thing given the very drinkable likeability of a more mellow palate.
The shade-grown, organic coffee is Swiss Water decaffeinated. This suggests the presence of zero harmful chemicals used during the extraction process of the coffee beans.
The taste is bold enough and, at the same time, it’s mellowed down with spice and cocoa finishes.
So if that sounds appealing to your taste buds, you’re all set, irrespective of whether you have a Keurig 1.0 or 2.0 brewer!
- Smooth medium-light decaf blend
- Chemical-free Swiss Water decaffeination
- Fully commercially compostable pods
- Kosher and USDA Organic certified
- Slightly bitter aftertaste
- Some grounds seep into the coffee
#4 Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Dark Magic Decaf
Let me begin by revealing that this is an affordable buy, so you don’t have to loosen your purse strings all that much.
The hint of dried fruit and chocolate is the most tempting aspect because, after all, it’s what opens the floodgates to the delicate, sweet finish, as long as you have any Keurig pod coffee maker.
The Dark Magic coffee is a hundred percent Arabica, so you can look forward to a savory and bright experience at whatever time of the day.
Each cup is well equipped to offer the caffeine jolt you crave. And the best part is that the jolt comes without any jitters.
- Extra-bold decaffeinated coffee
- Orthodox Union Kosher certified and 100% sustainable
- Hints of chocolate and dried fruit with a subtle, sweet finish
- Full-flavored and rich without any bitterness
#5 Tully’s Coffee French Roast Single-Serve Keurig K-Cup
There are many types of coffee drinkers.
Are you someone who prefers a deep and dark roast, but without the bitter caffeine? If yes, make room for the Tully’s Coffee French Roast K-Cups.
The ‘Francois’ roast is quite straightforward if you ask me. It’s the ideal roast level. This is great if you’re looking for the best regular French roast substitute.
The taste holds sumptuous dark chocolate tones with a bold flavor that has a slightly cocoa-type quality and mild acidity.
To make things even better for your taste buds, the finish is gentle and sweet.
So you have every reason to try this pod, also compatible with every Keurig brewer for K-cup pods.
- Made of Arabica coffee beans, hence less bitterness
- Rich-flavored with bittersweet chocolate and anise
- Strong brew holds up well to creamer for iced coffee
- Orthodox Union Kosher certified
- Complaints of pods exploding when pierced
- Slightly chemical aftertaste
#6 Peet’s Coffee Decaf House Blend Dark Roast Coffee
I’m going to keep it short and precise.
The only way to describe Peet’s Coffee Decaf House Blend Dark Roast is this: the coffee pods are full-bodied, well-balanced, super-bold, and bright. Let’s also add that the blend is packed with maximum aroma plus flavor, and deeply roasted to your liking!
These pods are compatible with all Keurig machines as well.
- Deeply roasted for a smoky, full-bodied flavor
- Delightful and sweet Latin blend
- Doesn’t lack depth (thanks to dark roast!) yet no bitterness
- Not for those who don’t prefer a toasty taste
#7 The Original Donut Shop Single-Serve K-Cup Pods
The quintessential balance between bitter and bold, you get that right?
If you do, you’re more likely to think highly of The Original Donut Shop K-Cup Pods. They’re Kosher-certified, medium-roasted, and bold tasting.
The fresh flavor is the kind that lasts long and the aroma is equally enchanting. Simply put, that’s all I could conclude after putting this coffee to the test.
So don’t think twice before pairing it up with your pastries. Not very bitter, not very harsh; the taste is simply perfect.
You can enjoy this medium roast with just about any K-cup coffee maker by Keurig i.e. both 1.0 and 2.0 models!
- Extra bold with more coffee grounds per K-cup
- Medium roast, thus full-bodied and rich-flavored
- Blend is easy on the tummy
- Orthodox Union Kosher certified
- Leaves you feeling jittery
#8 Starbucks Decaf Pike Place Roast K Cups
Do you know what’s surprisingly good?
It’s the Starbucks Decaf K Cups. They’re bold and beautiful, with no caffeine, yet the coffee flavor is pretty strong.
The subtle hints of toasted nuts and cocoa are very well balanced, and the overall taste is extremely smooth and rich as far as my opinion goes.
Needless to say, these K-cups make it seem like you’re not drinking decaf at all.
One other truthful claim by the manufacturer is the compatibility part. Yes, this Starbucks coffee does work in all Keurig brewers.
- Subtle, smooth flavors of toasted nuts and cocoa
- Full-flavored without tasting diluted or weak
- Starbucks standard, thus high quality and value for money
- A little too bitter and acidic
#9 Green Mountain Coffee Medium Roast K-Cups
Yet another praiseworthy blend manufactured by Green Mountain Coffee Roasters.
The Vermont Country Blend decaf coffee consists of dark and light beans, the outcome of which is a heavenly blend of rich and sweet.
It’s even plenty aromatic if my olfactory senses are to be taken seriously.
Each K-cup pod is flooded with flavor. The coffee is dark enough, and at the same time, there’s no hint of the unpleasant “caffeine bite” in the end.
That means minimal acidity, which is splendid news since you wish to buy the best decaf K-cups for your 1.0 or 2.0 Keurig machine!
- Medium roast made of flavorful, sweet Arabica beans
- Smooth and well-balanced with a toasty flavor
- Notes of sweet brown sugar in the aftertaste
- No bitter or nasty aftertaste
- Slightly weaker tasting, strength-wise
Different Types of Decaffeinated K-Cups
When it comes to describing the kinds of decaf K-cups, there are three parameters to keep in mind.
Type Of Coffee Beans
The lion’s share of decaffeinated AND caffeinated K-cup brands put to work Arabica beans.
It offers unique quality and taste. No two ways about that! But these two factors also depend on where the Arabica coffee beans are grown.
For instance, some caffeine enthusiasts prefer coffee that comes from Africa or South America, while others prefer Colombian beans.
So you might want to have a look at the type of coffee first. And where it’s grown!
Level of Roast
The first thing that comes to mind when talking about the roasting process is the final result. It’s because roasting transforms the nature of coffee beans.
The two factors that play a significant role are how long the beans have been roasted and what method is used.
Dark roast falls in the category of French, Italian, and Viennese roast. Medium roast is classified as full city+, fully city, city+, or city roast.
As for light roast, its common names include moderate-light, half city, Cinnamon, and American roast.
You’ve read through the reviews section, right? If yes, then I don’t need to tell you that flavored cups are quite a common occurrence now.
These additional flavors might be vanilla, hazelnut, mountain blueberry, etc.
So it’s only natural to assume that they have a huge impact on the taste of your hot cup of decaffeinated coffee.
Factors to Take Into Consideration When Buying Decaf K-Cups
Even decaffeinated K-cups offer a mix of everything as far as the flavor goes. Let’s assume we’re talking about a medium roast coffee here.
The most common tastes revolve around chocolate, citrus, and fruits. After all, not all pod coffee tastes the same, right?
On top of that, each manufacturer adds a distinctive flavor as well to meet the growing demands of devoted coffee lovers!
So what does this mean?
If your taste buds are picky, it’s better to try a flavor you know you’re more likely to enjoy. If not, then being a little experimental might just prove to be a very tasteful decision.
In the reviews section, I have made it a point to mention each pod’s Keurig machine compatibility.
And since I’ve done that, I know not all K-cups here get along with the 2.0 models of Keurig. Therefore it’s not just important but NECESSARY to check the compatibility before buying.
Now you probably know that decaf coffee is guilt-free coffee. But how is it decaffeinated? That’s something you should be aware of.
For example, if the Swiss Water process is used, you can rest assured knowing that your K-cups contain zero harmful chemicals.
Kosher-certified pods are always clearly labeled. But when in doubt, don’t hesitate to verify and confirm on the website of the manufacturer.
Many people don’t know what Kosher Certification really is, so if you’re one of them, find out all about it here.
Quantity Of K-Cups In The Package
This factor is kind of an important one if you simply can’t get enough of decaf coffee, and also if budget is a priority.
A pack of 24 decaf K-cups is certainly more affordable than buying the 24 pods individually, as 24 K-cups are equal to 24 single coffee servings.
As a bonus, some manufacturers offer a variety pack where you can choose different-tasting K-cups every time.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Can Decaf Keep You Awake?
The short answer is no. The long answer is that with the amount of caffeine left in your typical decaffeinated K-cup (see below) you are unlikely to feel any of the effects well known to normal coffee drinkers.
If you still have trouble falling asleep after a decaf cup, it means two things: either you have too many things on your mind, or you drank a regular coffee cup by mistake.
How Much Caffeine Is in a Decaf K-Cup?
Very little. While a regular cup of coffee has around 100 milligrams of caffeine, a decaf one has less than 5 milligrams. That’s at least 95% (i.e. 20 times) less. For reference, a double espresso might go all the way up to 150 milligrams.
Does Starbucks Make Decaf K Cups?
Why, yes, they do. I included one of theirs under #9 above. Do check it out.
Is Decaf Coffee Bad for Your Kidneys?
The problem might not be with the coffee itself, but with what comes along with it. For example, it can increase your potassium levels above the healthy margin, or your kidneys might need to work extra while processing the flavored syrup and creamer (which can also contain gluten!).
Single-serve decaf K-cup pods are quite the sensation now in the United States.
The 10 options I reviewed in this article are surely on their way to replace the conventional coffee pot thanks to their convenience and exquisite taste.
Once you lay your hands (or taste buds) on any single one, you’ll understand why K-cups are gaining so much popularity.