The Best Plastic Free Coffee Maker: 2021 Reviews & Buying Guide

Best Overall
BUNN BX Speed Brew Classic 10-Cup Coffee Brewer, Black
OXO BREW 9 Cup Programmable Coffee Maker, Silver
Presto 02811 12-Cup Stainless Steel Coffee Maker
SterlingPro French Press Coffee Maker (1L)-Double Walled Large Coffee Press with...
Coffee Gator Paperless Pour Over Coffee Dripper Brewer 14oz Clear
Our Score
9.4
9.1
8.9
8.5
8.2
MSRP
$142.93
$195.95
$51.06
$36.86
$32.99
Capacity
10 Cups
12 Cups
12 Cups
10 Cups
3 Cups
Material
Stainless Steel
Stainless Steel
Stainless Steel
Stainless Steel
Paperless Stainless Steel Filter and BPA-Free Glass Carafe
Warranty
3 Years
2 Years
2 Years
N/A
N/A
Best Overall
BUNN BX Speed Brew Classic 10-Cup Coffee Brewer, Black
Our Score
9.4
MSRP
$142.93
Capacity
10 Cups
Material
Stainless Steel
Warranty
3 Years
More Information
OXO BREW 9 Cup Programmable Coffee Maker, Silver
Our Score
9.1
MSRP
$195.95
Capacity
12 Cups
Material
Stainless Steel
Warranty
2 Years
More Information
Presto 02811 12-Cup Stainless Steel Coffee Maker
Our Score
8.9
MSRP
$51.06
Capacity
12 Cups
Material
Stainless Steel
Warranty
2 Years
More Information
SterlingPro French Press Coffee Maker (1L)-Double Walled Large Coffee Press with...
Our Score
8.5
MSRP
$36.86
Capacity
10 Cups
Material
Stainless Steel
Warranty
N/A
More Information
Coffee Gator Paperless Pour Over Coffee Dripper Brewer 14oz Clear
Our Score
8.2
MSRP
$32.99
Capacity
3 Cups
Material
Paperless Stainless Steel Filter and BPA-Free Glass Carafe
Warranty
N/A
More Information

How many of you can’t start the day without a dose of that powerful potion known as coffee?

Yeah, I thought so – pretty much everyone. But let me ask you something:

How many of you make sure your morning ritual is plastic-free, as well?

With the growing popularity of going green and the overall consciousness about the effect of plastic on our planet, I think it’s time for you to make the transition to a plastic-free coffee maker, too.

Let’s review & compare some of the top-performing products on the market.

1. Best Drip Coffee Maker: Technivorm Moccamaster Coffee Brewer

Technivorm Moccamaster Coffee Brewer

This high-end coffee machine is made of BPA-free plastics and it has a stainless steel filter.

These provide enough evidence of its eco-friendliness, but it’s also an efficient brewer capable of producing delicious coffee whenever you need it.

It features a 40oz container that can have your coffee ready in six minutes. 

With the highest quality coffee in mind, the minds behind this brewer enhanced it with a copper heating component, ensuring your coffee is brewed at the optimal temperature.

Besides, you can rest assured that your coffee will not get overheated or burned, as the water won’t go above the boiling point.

What this temperature-controlled environment offers for you is the experience of fully-flavored coffee.

Another remarkable feature is its speed. You can set the brewing speed and the limit, and have your coffee made in mere minutes.

Moccamaster is equipped with numerous controls that enhance the overall experience. 

Among the most notable ones is the automatic brew-basket, which makes sure that there is no spillage when the glass carafe is pulled away.

On top of these, Moccamaster guarantees that you will not have to worry about your coffee-brewer with an auto shut-down control. This makes sure that your machine will automatically turn off after 100 minutes.

The manufacturers guarantee a five-year-long warranty as well!

PROS

CONS

OXO BREW 9 Cup Coffee Maker

OXO BREW 9 Cup Coffee Maker

Next, we have something that looks a bit more like the modern-day coffee makers you’re used to having in your kitchen.

What makes it unique, though?

The microprocessor controls the brew cycle and replicates the pour-over method. 

So, although the unit looks fancy, it comes down to a simple coffee brewing method. 

Paired with the Rainmaker Shower Head, which ensures uniform saturation of the coffee grounds, it gives you a perfect cup of coffee every time.

It’s also easy to use – the LED user interface is quite intuitive, and allows you to quickly adjust the timer, as well as the number of cups you’re brewing.

The Barista Brain is super expensive, though, especially when you compare it to the other models on the list.

Lastly, you should know that, due to its size, this OXO coffee maker takes up a lot of room and doesn’t fit under kitchen cabinets. 

It’s not a huge deal, but if you’re already struggling with space, it might not be the best option for you.

PROS

CONS

2. Best French Press Coffee Maker: SterlingPro French Press Coffee Maker

French Press Stainless Steel Coffee/Tea Maker

Remember what I said earlier about French presses

Well, this model by SterlingPro might be the perfect example of that – a simple design wrapped up in an insanely durable stainless steel body. 

And as if that weren’t enough, is very affordable, too!

What caught my eye is the double-wall design, though. The interior wall helps keep your coffee warm, while the outer one remains cool to the touch. 

Furthermore, the two screens will make sure your coffee stays free of sediments.

It doesn’t stop at coffee, either – this non-toxic coffee maker is suitable for making tea, hot chocolate, and even fruit-infused water!

Because of its stainless steel body, there’s no way for you to check the water level, so you’re either going to have to play the guessing game or measure it out before you pour it into the French press – it’s up to you.

Also, don’t be startled by the screeching sound that the parts make during the process. It’s something you can expect when metal comes in contact with metal.

PROS

CONS

Frieling USA Double Wall French Press Coffee Maker

Frieling USA Double Wall French Press Coffee Maker

If you are looking for durability above anything else, you know that the wisest solution is to turn to French Presses.

With no easy components to shatter, damage, or break, I will point you in the direction of one of the perfect stainless-steel French Presses by Frieling.

To begin mapping its qualities, I will start with its ultra-modern, uncompromising design. Its strengths lie in a double-wall, stainless steel container of an outstanding 36oz capacity with 10 inches in height.

Diving in deeper, you will find that this stainless-steel coffee brewer features no plastic parts.

The thermal carafe will make sure that your scorching-hot coffee remains scorching-hot.

If you opt for a different, cooler option, you have nothing to worry about. If you decide to brew iced coffee, it will remain cold.

What seems to be the controlling issue in the sphere of French presses is how difficult (or easy) they are for maintenance. Our choice presents no challenge as it is straightforward to clean and maintain. It is relatively simple to assemble and disassemble to be thoroughly cleaned.

To put your worries at rest, your stainless-steel Frieling won’t be worn down use after use. The charm is that this French press will look as good as new no matter how many times you use it.

PROS

CONS

3. Best Pour-Over Coffee Maker: Chemex Classic Series Pour-Over Coffee Maker

Chemex Classic Series Pour-Over Coffee Maker

The incessant wave of trends will have you believe that pour-over coffee is something astonishingly new.

Truth be told, it’s far from new, and it can even be considered a timeless classic. You need evidence, don’t you?

Let the Chemex Classic Coffeemaker be our witness and our evidence.

This coffee maker features a simplistically classic, aesthetically-pleasing design combined with high-quality materials that ultimately delivers outstanding performance while looking good.

It’s made with borosilicate glass that will absorb neither odors nor chemical residues, and it’s fairly easy to clean and maintain. However, you must be warned that, although this glass is both thick and of high quality, it’s not made to be thrown around carelessly.

Of course, the type of coffee that you like will play a role in selecting the perfect coffee maker.

Chemex will deliver the best of the best in the black filter coffee section. Cater your Chemex, and in turn, it will cater to you. The full-flavor, rich aroma of your coffee will leave your taste buds spoiled and changed forever.

As a reminder that not everything comes easy, the coffee from your Chemex demands practice to make it perfect. So, my recommendation is – give it time!

PROS

CONS

Hario V60 Ceramic Pour Over

Hario V60 Ceramic Pour Over Coffee Dripper

The problem with shiny new gadgets is that they come one after the other constantly, each one brighter and more interesting than the one before.

With all those entertaining options, people quickly grow bored and discard the previously “much-needed” electronic devices.

For the true lovers of the coffee-making process, I have selected the Hario V60.

Bear in mind that this will require both attention and effort. 

It’s designed with simplicity and elegance in mind, with a ceramic body that retains heat to deliver a constant temperature throughout the entire brewing time. 

This pour-over coffee maker is not precisely beginner-friendly, but all beginners can turn experts quickly if they invest time. 

That being said, the entire coffee brewing process can be a handful to master all at once. Still, I promise that the journey is rewarding and that you’ll have a completely satisfactory, strong, and rich coffee waiting for you.

Hario V60 is easy to clean and maintain. Also, it’s easy to carry, which is a bonus in itself once you are completely turned into a coffee aficionado, as you won’t stand the smell of coffee other than the one you make.

PROS

CONS

Coffee Gator Pour Over Brewer

Pour Over Brewer

Want to take part in saving the environment? 

Then, I highly suggest that you use this plastic-free coffee maker and do something good for Mother Earth. 

I loved how it doesn’t rely on paper coffee filters which can be a huge waste, especially if you often drink coffee.

Instead of having paper filters, this coffee maker comes with a long-lasting stainless steel mesh filter. 

This isn’t one of those flimsy products you have in the kitchen. It can withstand the test of time!

With the BPA-free construction of this coffee maker, you can be sure that there are no toxic chemicals that can get into your drink!

The simplicity of its use is another thing that made me fall in love with it. 

This is not one of those complicated models that will take a while to figure out.

It is pretty much straightforward, although it might take quite a while before your coffee is ready.

Still not convinced? 

Well, you might change your mind when I tell you that the manufacturer is offering a risk-free purchase. 

If you’re unhappy, all you need to do is let them know and return it within 30 days. They’ll give your money back without asking any questions!

PROS

CONS

4. Best Coffee Percolator: Presto 02811 12-Cup Stainless Steel Coffee Maker

Presto 02811 12-Cup Stainless Steel Coffee Maker

The coffee-drinking culture blossomed into various beautiful and intricate branches, each offering a different taste and outlook. 

Over many years of enjoying coffee, percolators have solidified their place as a favorite option.

This one is no different, and it comes from a line of established manufacturers and is exactly as I love them – traditionally made and designed with splashes of modernity just enough not to make it seem like a rocket ship of confusion.

Presto 12-Cup stainless steel coffee maker is the ideal solution that finds the intricate balance between careful and elegant design while not going overboard and being easy to maintain.

Whether you want a cup or twelve cups, the strength and the quality of your coffee is the same. Presto 12-Cup makes it and then keeps it nice and hot.

Made of stainless steel, it’s a promising coffee maker made to last and serve you for a long time. The most important thing about it is that your caffeinated drink will never come in contact with plastic!

To top it all off, the manufacturers made it possible to detach the power cord, which enhances its portability. 

PROS

CONS

Farberware 8-Cup Percolator Stainless Steel

Farberware 8-Cup Percolator Stainless Steel

Do you remember percolators, the iconic coffee makers that were all the rage back in the seventies? 

Well, it seems like they’re making a comeback! 

If you’re looking for a simple solution to your never-ending quest for a flavorful cup of coffee, this is the one.

It’s an electrically-powered no-plastic coffee maker, capable of brewing a cup of coffee in a minute. 

On top of that, the “keep warm” feature kicks in automatically to help keep your coffee at a perfect temperature for as long as you need.

Moreover, thanks to the heat-resistant handle and lid knob, the chances of burning your hand while handling it are minimal.

However, you have to keep in mind that this unit doesn’t come with an auto shut-off feature – the responsibility of pulling the plug is on you. 

So, remember to unplug it once it’s done brewing, or you might end up burning the coffee.

The fill lines are hard to see, too, so I’d suggest you measure out your water before you pour it into the reservoir.

PROS

CONS

5. Best Moka Pot Coffee Maker: Bialetti 06800 Express Moka Pot

Bialetti 06800 Express Moka Pot

For those among you who love to drink their coffee as Italians do, Bialetti 06800 Express Moka is here to set the standard for mocha brewers.

A household name when it comes to coffee making, Bialetti’s design is an eye-catching classic. If you find yourself wondering whether the original among many products can be beaten by mere imitation, I have to tell you that it cannot.

While often imitated, Bialetti’s unique design and the brewing process cannot be replicated. 

This handy coffee maker is compatible with both electric and gas stoves, so you can cross that off from the list of your doubts.

Those of you who favor a strong espresso to start your busy days will find Bialetti’s Express Moka to be a delightful addition to your morning routine.

It doesn’t deliver a single bad brew, but a consistently warm and energizing cup of coffee to start the day.

While it’s easy to clean and to disassemble, bear in mind that this high-quality aluminum is not dishwasher-safe, so don’t make the mistake of putting it there to be cleaned.

All in all, coffee lovers will delight in this stovetop espresso maker, as it promises a divine adventure and a quick trip to Italy, albeit in your mind!

PROS

CONS

Why’s It Time To Ditch Plastic: Opt For A Non-Toxic Morning Ritual

non-toxic coffee maker

For me, you need three things to make good coffee: organic coffee beans, a good grinder, and, most importantly, a non-toxic coffee maker.

Therefore, If you’re not yet convinced of replacing your old coffee maker with a non-plastic one, I’ll give you three more reasons:

Are Plastic Coffee Makers Safe?

They are not safe.

There are many chemicals in them, and Bisphenol A (BPA), used to harden plastics, is at the forefront of those chemicals in terms of capacity to create health hazards.

BPA may easily leak from your machine into your drink, and if you’re a regular coffee drinker, it’s certainly not something you’d want in your daily intake.

Researches show that it affects hormonal activity to an extent that can cause infertility, diabetes, and heart diseases.

The FDA has not yet banned the use of BPA since they claim that the leaking amount is not enough to cause serious damage, but do you want to take that risk?

Plastic And Heat Don’t Go Well Together

Okay, I’m pretty sure everyone knows this, so I don’t get how plastic parts that come into direct contact with piping hot water get a free pass from the coffee drinkers.

Every time hot liquid passes through the plastic parts, there’s a chance some of the dangerous chemicals will be released into it, and find their way into your body.

If it were a one-time thing, it wouldn’t be an issue, but for daily coffee drinkers, there are some severe consequences of not switching to a plastic-free machine.

Do You Like Your Coffee Hot and Moldy?

Sounds awful, right? 

But here’s the thing – if you’re still using a coffee maker with plastic parts, chances are some mold spores are floating around in your cup of coffee as we speak. 

It’s warm, dark, and moist – it’s no wonder mold and mildew want to move into your coffee maker.

If that’s not a wake-up call, I don’t know what is!

Choosing A Non-Plastic Coffee Maker: Things To Consider Before Buying

Couple Buying Coffee Maker

I’m assuming this isn’t your first time shopping for a coffee maker, so you probably already know the usual factors that go into the decision-making process, such as:

  • The unit’s capacity
  • Room for customizations (temperature, brew strength)
  • The space it takes up on your kitchen counter
  • How easy it is to use and clean
  • The price tag

However, it might be your first time buying a non-plastic coffee maker, which could leave you feeling a bit confused and clueless as to how to pick the right one.

The most important thing you need to remember – and pay attention to – is the use of plastic parts.

Sure, a plastic handle won’t do much harm, and you can let that one slide, but if any plastic pieces come in direct contact with the water or the coffee grounds, it’s a huge no-no!

Now, I know you might be worried that you’ll be left with a relatively limited choice of coffee makers if you decide to eliminate plastic out of the equation.

However, rest assured that going green doesn’t mean sacrificing your coffee-drinking experience.

  • French Press – When I think of rich coffee flavors, I think of French presses. It always amazes me how something so simple can add a touch of luxury to a cup of coffee. If you want extra durability, go with a stainless steel one.
  • Percolator – If you want a simple, somewhat old-fashioned solution, a percolator is a way to go. Simplicity is their most significant advantage – without any additional equipment, all you need to do is plug it in, and you’ll have your coffee ready in a matter of minutes.
  • Pour Over – The name pretty much says it all – pour hot water over your coffee grounds and let gravity handle the rest. It takes time, but the quality is fantastic. Plus, it’s one of the cheapest ways to transition to a non-plastic coffee maker.

Are All Mr. Coffee Makers BPA-Free?

Mr. Coffee is a prominent brand, and understandably, you might have taken a fancy to one of their machines.

However, if you want to get a non-toxic coffee maker, let me warn you that not all of their products are BPA-free.

For example, this Mr. Coffee espresso machine is made of plastic and contains BPA, which might or might not come into contact with your beverage.

Nonetheless, they have BPA-free coffee makers, too. 

To understand which products meet these criteria, you can always look at the product specifications on Amazon. Most of the companies nowadays feel that it’s necessary to let the customers know if their products are BPA-free.

Is the Ninja Coffee Maker BPA-Free?

Yes, all Ninja coffee makers are BPA-free.

They use aluminum or stainless steel on parts contacting hot water – like boilers or filter baskets.

There might be plastics used in other parts of their products, but they make sure that these plastics are BPA-free.

Our Verdict 

Okay. So, you’ve done your research and checked out some of the best models the market has to offer, so the next logical step is to ask yourself the following.

Which one of these is the best plastic-free coffee maker?

For me, it’s the super affordable, multi-purpose Sterling Pro French Press.

Ultimately, though, whichever one you end up buying, you’re still making a big step in the right direction – one that leads to a more eco-friendly lifestyle.

Related Posts

The Best K Cups Coffee – Top 27 Picks Of All Time

The Best K Cups Coffee – Top 27 Picks of All Time

Inescapable; that’s one word to describe the best K cup coffee. Coffee pods have invaded many home kitchen counters and office spaces.  The chances are …

Read More →
The Best Dual Coffee Makers For Quick Coffee Brewing In 2019

Top 4 Best Dual Coffee Makers for Quick Brewing in 2021

The reason that coffee makers are great is that they save you so much of your precious time.  But what if they could be even …

Read More →
Best Organic Coffee K-Cups 2020: Healthy Can Be Tasty Too!

Best Organic Coffee K-Cups 2021: Healthy Can Be Tasty Too!

K-cups are the best gifts from the coffee gods! Any caffeine lover will surely agree with me on this! With K-cups, guesswork is eliminated when …

Read More →