The 8 Best Coffee Maker Without Plastic: 2019’s Buying Guide [Updated]

Best Overall
BUNN BX Speed Brew Classic 10-Cup Coffee Brewer, Black
OXO BREW 9 Cup Coffee Maker
Presto 02811 12-Cup Stainless Steel Coffee Maker
French Press Coffee Maker (1L) - Double Walled 18/10 Large Coffee Press with 2...
Pour Over Coffee Dripper - Coffee Gator Paperless Pour Over Coffee Maker -...
Our Score
9.4
9.1
8.9
8.5
8.2
MSRP
$104.38
$199.95
$44.00
$35.95
$25.99
Capacity
10 Cups
12 Cups
12 Cups
10 Cups
3 Cups
Material
Stainless Steel
Stainless Steel
Stainless Steel
Stainless Steel
Paperless Stainless Steel Filter and BPA-Free Glass Carafe
Warranty
3 Years
2 Years
2 Years
N/A
N/A
Best Overall
BUNN BX Speed Brew Classic 10-Cup Coffee Brewer, Black
Our Score
9.4
MSRP
$104.38
Capacity
10 Cups
Material
Stainless Steel
Warranty
3 Years
More Information
OXO BREW 9 Cup Coffee Maker
Our Score
9.1
MSRP
$199.95
Capacity
12 Cups
Material
Stainless Steel
Warranty
2 Years
More Information
Presto 02811 12-Cup Stainless Steel Coffee Maker
Our Score
8.9
MSRP
$44.00
Capacity
12 Cups
Material
Stainless Steel
Warranty
2 Years
More Information
French Press Coffee Maker (1L) - Double Walled 18/10 Large Coffee Press with 2...
Our Score
8.5
MSRP
$35.95
Capacity
10 Cups
Material
Stainless Steel
Warranty
N/A
More Information
Pour Over Coffee Dripper - Coffee Gator Paperless Pour Over Coffee Maker -...
Our Score
8.2
MSRP
$25.99
Capacity
3 Cups
Material
Paperless Stainless Steel Filter and BPA-Free Glass Carafe
Warranty
N/A
More Information

Note: Our comparison table only shows our top 5 picks. You can find the other recommendations within this article.

How many of you can’t start their day without a dose of that powerful potion known as coffee?

Yeah, I thought so – pretty much everyone. But let me ask you something:

How many of you make sure their morning ritual is plastic-free, as well?

With the growing popularity of “going green” and the overall consciousness about the effect of plastic on our planet, I think it’s time for you to make the transition to a plastic-free coffee maker, too.

Let’s review & compare some of the top-performing product on the market.

Our Reviews For The Best Plastic Free Coffee Makers 2019 (Non-Toxic & Safe)

#1 Bunn Bunn Bx-B Velocity Coffee Brewer

Bunn Bunn Bx-B Velocity Coffee Brewer

Okay, this no-plastic coffee maker lives up to its name “Velocity.” 

The fact that it only takes about three minutes to brew up to 10 cups of coffee is what first inspired me to give it a try.

As it turns out, the reservoir is what keeps this unit ready for action at all times – the built-in heater works overtime so that the water never loses its temperature, even if it sits in there for hours.

Furthermore, I love the drip-free spout design featured on the glass carafe. 

If you’re anything like me, you’ll appreciate a little extra help not spilling your morning dose of coffee all over the counter by accident.

Now, there’s a fine line between keeping the coffee hot and burning it, and this unit’s warming plate crossed it – there’s no way to regulate the plate’s temperature, which could result in some bitter-tasting coffee.

Also, I’ve noticed that the water keeps evaporating from the tank because it’s kept continuously warm. 

So, if you don’t plan on using the unit for quite some time, turning it off might be the right thing to do.

#2 Oxo On Barista Brain 9 Cup Coffee Maker

OXO BREW 9 Cup Coffee Maker

Next, we have something that looks a bit more like the modern-day coffee makers you’re used to having in your kitchen.

What makes it unique, though?

The microprocessor controls the brew cycle and replicates the pour-over method. 

So, although the unit looks all fancy, it mostly comes down to a reasonably simple coffee brewing method. 

Paired with the Rainmaker Shower Head, which ensures uniform saturation of the coffee grounds, it gives you a perfect cup of coffee every time.

Another thing worth mentioning is that it’s easy to use – the LED user interface is quite intuitive, and allows you to quickly adjust the timer, as well as the number of cups you’re brewing.

The Barista Brain is super expensive, though, especially when you compare it to the other models on the list.

Lastly, you should know that, due to its size, this OXO coffee maker takes up a lot of room and doesn’t quite fit under kitchen cabinets. 

It’s not a huge deal (pun intended), but if you’re struggling with space as it is, it might not be the best option for you.

#3 Presto 02811 12-Cup Stainless Steel Coffee Maker

Presto 02811 12-Cup Stainless Steel Coffee Maker

As it comes with a 12-cup capacity, this can be an ideal choice for large household or even for the office! Despite this, it comes with a space-efficient design.

This is also perfect for those who are looking for simplicity. It is one of those coffee makers without room for complications. 

There are no complicated controls or settings. It may not have the bells and whistles of its more expensive counterparts, but, rest assured, the performance is never compromised.

In terms of construction, it is made of a luxurious stainless steel, which is also known for its durability. It has excellent insulation to keep your drink hot. 

The perk tube and the inner basket are also made of stainless steel. This is also an easy-pour spout that will minimize mess as you transfer your drink in a cup.

You will never have to be left guessing when your coffee is ready to be enjoyed. 

In the bottom part, there is a signal light that will provide an immediate notification when coffee has been brewed.

The simplicity, however, can also be a drawback for some people. What this means is that you won’t have the freedom to customize your drink, especially based on the strength of the brew.

#4 French Press Stainless Steel Coffee/Tea Maker

French Press Stainless Steel Coffee/Tea Maker

Remember what I said earlier about French presses? 

Well, this model by SterlingPro might be the perfect example of that – a simple design wrapped up in an insanely durable stainless steel body. 

And as if that weren’t enough, is very affordable, too!

What caught my eye is the double-wall design, though. The interior wall helps keep your coffee or tea warm, while the outer one remains cool to the touch. 

Furthermore, the two screens will make sure your coffee stays free of any stray grounds.

It doesn’t stop at coffee, either – this no-plastic coffee maker is suitable for making tea, hot chocolate, and even fruit-infused water!

Now, because of its stainless steel body, there’s no way for you to check the water level, so you’re either going to have to play the guessing game or measure it out before you pour it into the French press – it’s up to you.

Also, don’t be startled by the screeching sound that the parts make during the process. It’s something you can expect when metal comes in contact with metal, though.

#5 Coffee Gator Pour Over Brewer

Want to take part in saving the environment? 

Then, I highly suggest that you use this plastic-free coffee maker and do something good for Mother Earth. 

I loved how it does not rely on paper filters. The latter can be a huge waste, especially if you often drink coffee.

Instead of having paper filters, this coffee maker comes with a stainless steel mesh filter, which is also long-lasting. 

This isn’t one of those flimsy products you have in the kitchen. It can withstand the test of time!

With the BPA-free construction of this coffee maker, you can be sure that there are no toxic chemicals that can get into your drink!

The simplicity of using this product is one more thing that made me fall in love with it. 

This is not one of those complicated models that will take a while to figure out how it can be used.

It is pretty much straightforward, although, the problem is that it might take quite a while before your coffee is ready.

Still not convinced? 

Well, you might change your mind when I tell you that the manufacturer is offering a risk-free purchase. 

If you are unhappy, all that you need to do is let them know and return it within 30 days. They will give your money back without asking any question!

#6 Chemex Classic Series Pour-Over Coffee Maker

Chemex Classic Series Pour-Over Coffee Maker

Simple and elegant – these are two words that can perfectly sum up what this product is all about. 

This is different from those that have been mentioned above in the sense that it is not electric. It is like a pitcher or a carafe. 

When coffee is brewed, you can have the carafe covered and have it refrigerated.

There is no function that keeps the coffee warm. Nonetheless, you can put it in a glass stove top or a gas flame, provided that there is low heat. 

Take note that the manufacturer strongly advises against using it in an electric coil stove top.

It is made of borosilicate glass. Before you freak out, take note that it is not the type of glass that is fragile. It is thick enough to withstand low heat and last long. 

Plus, the glass is also non-porous. This prevents the absorption of chemicals and odors that can have a negative impact in the flavor of your coffee. 

This way, you can expect only the purest taste from your caffeine fix.

#7 Melitta Coffee Maker, 6 Cup Pour-Over Brewer With Glass Carafe

Melitta 6-Cup Pour-Over Coffee Brewer

First, let us have a quick brush up of your history. 

The traditional paper filters used in coffee makers were invented in 1908 by Melitta Bentz. That is from where this brand got its name!

Looking at the coffee maker, it is designed much like any traditional pour-over, but it has a hint of flare to make it stylish.

The glass carafe has been underwhelming for some users, with some noting that there can be durability issues. 

However, it is a good thing that it can hold up to 36 ounces of coffee, which will allow it to hold up to eight cups.

I also love how ergonomic the handle is. This makes it easy to hold it on your hand. Plus, it does not get hot! 

Of course, it gets hot if you hold it from the glass. And not the handle Don’t be a fool to do that!

The price is also impressive. It is easy on the wallet, and this is even made better by the fact that the kit is already inclusive with #4 cone filters from Melitta.

Want to know the secret on how to make better coffee using this product? 

Simple! 

All that you have to do is to create a gentle swirling motion when you are pouring the hot water, which is going to improve the extraction.

#8 Farberware 8-Cup Percolator Stainless Steel

Farberware 8-Cup Percolator Stainless Steel

Do you remember percolators, the iconic coffee makers that were all the rage back in the seventies? 

Well, it seems like they’re making a comeback! 

If you’re looking for a simple solution to your never-ending quest to a flavorful cup of coffee, the Farberware percolator is the one.

It’s an electrically-powered no-plastic coffee maker, capable of brewing a cup of coffee in a minute or so. 

On top of that, the “keep warm” feature kicks in automatically to help keep your coffee at a perfect temperature for as long as you need.

Moreover, thanks to the heat-resistant handle and lid knob, the chances of burning your hand while handling the percolator are minimal – and that’s always a huge plus.

However, you have to keep in mind that this unit doesn’t come with an auto shut-off feature your previous coffee maker had – the responsibility of pulling the plug is on you. 

So, remember to unplug it once it’s done brewing, or you might end up burning the coffee.

The fill lines are hard to see, too, so I’d suggest you measure out your water before you pour it into the reservoir.

#9 Bodum Columbia French Press Coffee Maker

Bodum Columbia French Press Coffee Maker

This is for those who are on the lookout for a thermal French Press coffee maker. 

The simplicity of this product is also one of its best assets, although for some, this could be a restriction basically because of the lack of options for programmability.

The thermal carafe is also worth highlighting. It is thick and durable. More importantly, because of its insulated construction, you can expect that your drink won’t easily get cold. 

It is made of stainless steel with double-wall insulation that will keep your coffee hot for about two hours.

Another feature worth highlighting is the sealed lid, which has been developed exclusively by the manufacturer. This will prevent your coffee from accidentally spilling.

In terms of capacity, it can only hold 17 ounces. Roughly, this translates to four cups of coffee, which can be quite small.

Why’s It Time To Ditch Plastic: Opt For A Non-Toxic Morning Ritual

non-toxic coffee maker

If you’re not sold on the idea of replacing your old coffee maker with a non-plastic one, here are two significant reasons why you should do it as soon as possible:

Plastic And Heat Don’t Go Well Together

Okay, I’m pretty sure everyone knows this, so I don’t get how plastic parts that come into direct contact with piping hot water get a free pass from the coffee drinkers.

Every time hot liquid passes through the plastic parts, there’s a chance some of the dangerous chemicals found in them (such as BPA and phthalates) will be released into it, and find their way into your body.

If it were a one-time thing, it wouldn’t be an issue, but for daily coffee drinkers, there are some severe consequences of not switching to a plastic free coffee maker.

Do You Like Your Coffee Hot And Moldy?

Sounds awful, right? 

But here’s the thing – if you’re still using a coffee maker with plastic parts, chances are some mold spores are floating around in your cup of coffee as we speak. 

It’s warm, it’s dark, and it’s moist – it’s no wonder mold, and mildew want to move into your coffee maker.

If that’s not a wake-up call, I don’t know what is!

Oh, and while you’re at it, you should ditch the coffee pods, as well. They might be convenient, but they’re taking a toll on the environment.

Choosing A Non-Plastic Coffee Maker: Things To Consider Before Buying

I’m assuming this isn’t your first time shopping for a coffee maker, so you probably already know the usual factors that go into the decision-making process, such as:

  • The unit’s capacity
  • Does it leave room for customizations (temperature, brew strength)
  • How much space it takes up on your kitchen counter
  • How easy it is to use and clean
  • The price tag

However, it might be your first time buying a non-plastic coffee maker, which could leave you feeling a bit confused and clueless as to how to pick the right one.

The most important thing you need to remember – and pay attention to – is the use of plastic parts

Sure, a plastic handle won’t do much harm, and you can let that one slide, but if any plastic pieces come in direct contact with the water or the coffee grounds, it’s a huge no-no!

Now, I know you might be worried that you’ll be left with a relatively limited choice of coffee makers if you decide to eliminate plastic out of the equation. 

However, rest assured that going green doesn’t mean sacrificing your coffee-drinking experience.

  • French Press – When I think of rich coffee flavor, I think of French presses. It always amazes me how something so simple can add a touch of luxury to a cup of coffee. If you want extra durability, go with a stainless steel one
  • Percolator – If you want a simple, somewhat old-fashioned solution, a percolator is a way to go. Simplicity is their most significant advantage – without any additional equipment, all you need to do is plug it in, and you’ll have your coffee ready in a matter of minutes.
  • Pour Over – The name pretty much says it all – pour hot water over your coffee grounds and let gravity handle the rest. It takes time, but the quality is fantastic. Plus, it’s one of the cheapest ways to transition to a non-plastic coffee maker.

Verdict & The Best Pick

Okay, you’ve done your research and checked out some of the best models the market has to offer, so the next logical step is to ask yourself:

Which one of these is the best plastic-free coffee maker?

For me, it’s the super affordable, multi-purpose French Press Stainless Steel Coffee/Tea Maker.

Ultimately, though, whichever one you end up buying, you’re still making a big step in the right direction – one that leads to a more eco-friendly lifestyle.

About The Author